Semafor was caught paying $100,000 to a senior Trump adviser in a bombshell Washington Post exposé that ran Thursday. The transparency-touting news outlet never disclosed the financial relationship to its readers. That seriously undermines all of its journalistic authority. And yet the media reporter watchdog set has barely blinked.
The adviser is Jason Miller. The Post found the payment in financial records from his child-support case. Semafor confirmed it and said Miller helped book guests for its World Economy summit in Washington in April. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick spoke there. Semafor hasn’t said which guests Miller delivered.
Media reporters love to pounce in a signature groupthink manner when one journalist slips. But given a long-standing relationship with reporters at Semafor, it feels like they’ve looked the other way and shrugged.
After the bombshell Washington Post story dropped Thursday, Semafor added disclosures to 11 stories and newsletters on Friday. That's nearly a dozen stories whose readers weren't told Semafor was paying someone named in them. The disclosures also name two more paid consultants. Kellyanne Conway was Trump’s senior counselor. Adrienne Elrod was a senior adviser on Kamala Harris’s campaign. Both still work for Semafor, and the company hasn’t said what it pays them.
Semafor is a news startup launched by Ben Smith and Justin Smith in 2022, both well-regarded figures in the political media world. Ben previously served as the New York Times media columnist, and Justin ran Bloomberg Media. Its mission statement asserts that “global trust in the media is at an all-time low” before ironically promising it provides “audiences with an unparalleled level of journalistic transparency through innovative new forms, cutting through the noise of the news cycle with smart, distilled views and exploring competing perspectives across borders for a curious, new global audience.”
The site gets about 2 million visits a month by one outside estimate, a fraction of Politico’s traffic. Investors still put in $30 million in January at a $330 million valuation, which I can only believe is based on seeing the growth opportunity behind its seemingly lucrative event business. Semafor reportedly took in $40 million last year, and about half came from conferences where officials and CEOs are interviewed on stages that sponsors pay for.
New York Times reporter Ben Mullin pointed out on X that Semafor calls its events “live journalism.” At a live event, the guests are the content. So Semafor paid Jason Miller six figures to help deliver its content, and that’s as naked an example of access journalism as you can get.
Not paying sources might be the oldest rule in a newsroom. Semafor can argue that a booking fee is different and a necessary expense in the events business. The difference here gets thinner when the booker is a Trump insider that Semafor also covers. Smith admitted these consultants can be subjects of coverage, and it doesn't take much in the way of searching their site to see that they have been. Semafor paid them anyway, told almost no one, and claims to have kept most of its own newsroom in the dark.
Semafor’s target demographic is readers of power and influence. According to the site, 75% of Fortune 500 CEOs subscribe to its CEO newsletter. It’s unclear what percentage of those readers now know Semafor has been paying Washington operators and saying nothing about it. It’s not unfair to breathlessly call it “ultra-elitist,” as The Daily Beast did in a recent headline. Every story it runs about Trump’s circle raises the same question. Who else has been getting paid?
Semafor has defended itself. Spokesperson Meaghan Koppel told the Post the company hires bookers from both parties and doesn’t pay speakers. She said Semafor didn’t quote or mention Miller in its Washington coverage during his engagement, and made two passing references to him in business coverage. That statement covers only the period when Miller was on contract.
In a note sent to staff, Ben Smith wrote that the consultants “have no influence on our journalism, online or on our stages.” He said that most of the newsroom and events team didn’t know about them, and that leaders could have communicated better. He said news organizations don’t always disclose contracts like these. He promised Semafor will do so from now on when a consultant could be a subject of its coverage.
That promise is designed to relieve legitimate concerns, but it also plainly concedes the point of clear conflict. Semafor covers these paid consultants, both directly and indirectly, and readers should have been told from the start. The news outlet is asking for trust without showing proof. It hasn’t released a contract, a guest list, or a dollar figure for Conway, Elrod, or any other undisclosed individual currently on the Semafor payroll.
Smith knows this. He told The Verge a few months ago that paid political influencers reminded him of the old radio payola scandals. Insiders knew how it worked, he said, but “the audience was not in on the joke.” I’m not alleging payola, and nobody has shown these consultants bought coverage. But Smith’s own standard is enough.
Plenty of journalists have seen this massive problem clearly. Former Washington Post reporter Christopher Ingraham called it “legitimately nuts.” Both Defector and the Daily Beast ran scathing pieces.
The media beat was bizarrely much more forgiving. “This is not complicated,” former Washington Post columnist and CNN analyst Chris Cillizza wrote on X. Events need famous guests, he explained, and Miller has access to Trump’s people, which explains why he got paid. Curiously, he completely ignores the lack of disclosure in any reporting on Miller or his minions.
Cillizza is one example of how media reporters, usually eager to judge and chide anyone who runs afoul, simply look the other way here. CNN’s Reliable Sources gave it a brief mention in its Friday newsletter. Status gave the Semafor payment a short item with an eyes emoji on Friday, including Semafor's explanation and a link to the Post. It did put "Semafor's Payment Problem" in the subject line, and the item went out two hours before the Post reported the 11 disclosures. As far as I can tell, several other regulars on the beat have said nothing at all.
Status published an investigation over the weekend by Jon Passantino, who edited Friday’s newsletter. He found that CNN and CBS News haven’t told viewers about Elon Musk’s stake in their parent company. Both networks told him they’re editorially independent. Disclosure matters even when nobody has shown the coverage was compromised, or that’s the argument Passantino made with CNN and CBS News.
An investor’s stake and a booking contract are different things, and Status may have had the Musk story in the works for a while. It still shows that Status knows how to chase an undisclosed financial tie at a news organization. Semafor gave the same answer CNN and CBS gave, and on Friday Status printed it and moved on. Why the difference? It might be because Semafor's media reporter, Max Tani, is a former colleague of Oliver Darcy. Asked on X on Friday whether he’d cover the story, Tani answered “Yes.” As of this writing, he hasn’t.
I should say that I’ve been on the receiving end of this beat. Earlier this year, Semafor and Status both covered reporting errors I made and owned for the One Sheet, an $8 newsletter I wrote for Mediaite. The errors were mine, and I left the site soon after.
In my case, there was a great deal of what felt like an outraged groupthink pile-on. All's fair in love and war, and I own my past. But this Semafor conflict is a MUCH bigger deal, and it’s effectively getting ignored by the very same hall monitors eager to jump on any transgression by a media figure with whom they disagree. Replace the name Ben Smith with Bari Weiss in this story and heads would explode.
Media reporting is a small beat whose influence punches well above its weight. Its reporters know each other very well. They go to the same parties, share sources, and love to amplify each other’s work on social media in a rather naked log-rolling style that evokes an 8th-grade cafeteria table. Some work for companies that run their own events. They are not idiots and can readily see why a publisher wants a Cabinet secretary on stage and is willing to pay for it.
Reporters who understand exactly why a deal makes sense for the business can start judging it the way an executive would. Cillizza’s explanation would be more at home in a budget meeting, but a reader wants the transparency that Semafor promised but abjectly failed to deliver. A reader wants to know who’s paying whom. Nobody needs a conspiracy to produce that kind of groupthink.
Serious questions surrounding Semafor’s journalistic standards remain unanswered. Which guests did Jason Miller deliver to events? What exactly did Conway and Elrod do to get paid? Who in the newsroom knew, and how did it affect its coverage? How many other newsrooms do the same thing? Many of these questions have remained unanswered, but the fact that we are even asking them is a damaging scar on Semafor’s reputation.
The reporters who took One Sheet apart know how to get those answers. They applied the right standard to an $8 newsletter. A company with $40 million in revenue should meet it too.
That’s not complicated either.



